Pegasus Taverna

Reviews

• Robert Feen

  star star star star star 28 June 2026

  Ate in the outdoor patio. Grape leaves were fantastic. Hugh menu with many, many choices. Appetizers, lamb, beef, chicken, pork, salads, omelettes, desserts galore. Table service was spot-on. Prices are mostly moderate. All in all a wonderful dining experience. Will definitely return in the near future.

• Madison DePlonty

  star star star_border star_border star_border 15 June 2026

  I will start off saying the wait staff was friendly and attentive which is why I gave this place 2 stars. They were essentially the only redeeming quality of this establishment. From the outside I expected it to be very high quality and based off the vast menu and pricing I was looking forward to a good meal. My partner ordered the lamb gyro and I got the lake perch (I know it’s a Greek place but I was craving fried fish). His lamb was too salty and too chewy, he claims it was the worst lunch he’s ever had, he couldn’t even finish it. My fish was very chewy and the breading was soggy. I also got a side of okra which had a good taste but the texture was almost sickening. The bathrooms were also outdated and dirty and the floors were greasy and slippery. I think this place has a lot of potential but I would never recommend any of my friends to try it.

• Edmund Russell

  star star star_border star_border star_border 11 June 2026

  I would typically give this place 5 stars because I have been a loyal customer for many years. I usually enjoy the food. The last few visits have been less then pleasurable. The food has not been very good. For example, they sent out flaming cheese that was still cold and hard. Then the absolutely torch the cheese that came atop my meal. I hope the kitchen staff can get it back together. I would like to take my rating back to 5 stars.

• shell

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  I love Pegasus it is so nice. No hassle going downtown. Right down the street Superstar food Superstar service Superstar environment. The bartenders and the patio are all wonderful personable and willing to talk to you and help you love it. Great selections of wine great beers food is wonderful. Can I just say the bread hello they have the most beautiful bread

• Laurrie Simons

  star star star star_border star_border 4 June 2026

  Service was good. Food was good. But the seating was hard. Sat at a table with wood benches. The back had cushions, but no cushions for your bottom. It got to be uncomfortable after a while. Also, the lighting is not great for reading the menu, especially for older folks or people with eyesight issues.